2023 Main Stage Season

Lucky Stiff – March 3-19, 2023

Good People – May 12-28, 2023

Welcome to Sleepy Hollow – October 6-29, 2023

The Ultimate Christmas Show (abridged) – December 8-24, 2023

Good People

May 12-28, 2023

A heartfelt dramedy

Middle-aged Margie Walsh is a nice woman from a poor neighborhood. Some of her friends might even say she’s TOO nice. When she gets fired from yet another job, her landlord threatens eviction.  Determined to keep a roof over her daughter’s head, she turns to a former friend, who made it out of their neighborhood of Southie, as they call South Boston, for help finding a job. From the moment she steps into Dr. Michael Dillon’s office, tensions mount in this reunion of old friends as they navigate the decisions that led them down different life paths. An emotional, heartfelt drama broken up by poignant moments of laugh-aloud humor, Good People by David Lindsay-Abaire will have audiences debating what it means to do the right thing. 

Written by David Lyndsay-Abaire.

Welcome to Sleepy Hollow

October 6-29, 2023

A hauntingly Romantic musical thriller

Katrina Van Tassel feels like she’s outgrown the village school in Sleepy Hollow until an unwanted suitor and a fascinating new school teacher change her mind. Unfortunately, her jilted would-be lover isn’t the only obstacle in the way of her budding romance with the new headmaster Ichabod Crane. Shortly after arriving to town, Ichabod is haunted by the Woman in White and learns of the town’s horrifying history and legend of the headless horseman. Can the young couple defy human and supernatural interlopers to find happiness? Welcome to Sleepy Hollow by Heather Megill Reba is a thrillingly updated and Romantic ride through one of America’s most beloved tales.


Written by Heather Megill Reba.

The Ultimate Christmas Show (abridged)

December 8-24, 2023

Hilarious holiday fun

All faiths are welcome to the Annual Holiday Variety Show and Christmas Pageant at St. Everybody’s Non-Denominational Universalist Church, where we’ll believe anything. Unfortunately, none of the acts scheduled to perform have arrived, so three members are pressed into service to perform the entire Variety Show and Christmas Pageant by themselves. An irreverent, yet heartwarming, trip through the holidays, The Ultimate Christmas Show (Abridged) by Reed Martin & Austin Tickenor is festive, funny, physical, family fun as these Three Wise Guys send up and celebrate our favorite holiday traditions.

Written by Reed Martin & Austin Tickenor.

Lucky Stiff – Closed

March 3-19, 2023

A musical farce

An absurd musical full of misfits and miscreants trailing along after a dead man on holiday, Lucky Stiff, written by Lynn Ahrens and Stephen Flaherty, is “Weekend at Bernie’s” meets “You’ve Got Mail!” A co-production of OTC and Scripps Ranch Theatre, Lucky Stiff tells the story of Harry, an English shoe salesman who receives the unexpected news that he has inherited a fortune from his late Uncle Anthony, on the condition that he takes his uncle’s dead body on a special trip to Monte Carlo. If Harry refuses to fulfill all of his uncle’s last wishes exactly, the inheritance will go to the Universal Dog Home of Brooklyn. It doesn’t help matters that Rita, Tony’s lover with whom he embezzled $6 million behind her husband’s back, and her brother Vinnie, who she blamed for the crime, have their own schemes to get at the money. Based on the novel The Man Who Broke the Bank at Monte Carlo by Michael Butterworth, Lucky Stiff is a life-affirming comedy served up with a dash of danger featuring romance, disguises, farcical chases, and an omnipresent corpse.

Book and Lyrics by Lynn Ahrens. Music by Stephen Flaherty. 


Subscription Benefits Include:

The Best Seats: As a Subscriber, you are able to purchase tickets before they go on sale to the general public.  And enjoy the same seats all year long!

Unlimited Exchanges: We know things change and conflicts arise. As a subscriber, you may exchange your tickets as often as you like without charge.

Save! Subscribers enjoy a 10% discount on tickets and pay no per-ticket fees for their subscription package.

Registration for Summer Camp 2023 NOW OPEN!
This is default text for notification bar